What's New?
Search This Site
« It's a good life, Sadie Dog | Main | In search of Henry & Keiko »

My adventures at the Bay View (guilty by) Association

This is a kind of a "How I Spent My Summer Vacation" type of report, because there's good, there's bad, and there's even a coming-of-age moment for yours truly. This is about my recent visit to Bay View, Michigan, where I was honored and absolutely dee-lited that the literary powers-that-be chose Songs of Willow Frost for their Third Annual Bay View Reads selection.

I'd been to this part of Lake Michigan, namely last year, to Booktopia, and the thought of a few relaxing days away from the kids seemed like a slice of Heaven. Or heaven (lower-case), if you don't believe in Heaven (upper-case). More on that in a moment.

Peace pole in front of the church. Anyone speak Hebrew?When we arrived in Bay View we were blown away by its charm, its coziness, its Americana, and best of all, of the 440 cottages that comprise this community (Victorian vacation homes, really) we were billeted in the cottage formerly owned by Irma Rombauer who wrote The Joy of Cooking. The only bad part is that we'd feel guilty ordering pizza or mircowaving a Hot Pocket on such hallowed ground.

Then came the surprising, non-ironic, actual bad part.

We quickly learned that Jews are not allowed in Bay View. WHAT! ARE YOU FREAKIN' KIDDING ME?! IN THIS DAY AND AGE? Okay, calm down. It's not that bad, or that simple to understand. Don't fall for the sound bite. It's actually quite nuanced. Jewish people can rent (or as one Bay Viewer joked, "Hey, we don't mind their money,") but they can't become a member of the official resort community known as the Bay View Association.

Why? Because the Bay View Association was founded by Methodists and while the association is a non-profit organization, the vacation homes are on land leased from the association, and to purchase a home you must be approved by the association. And while fewer than half of the association members actually go to any church these days, that Christian requirement is used to keep people of other faiths, namely Jewish people, from joining. (Even though I was told that the Methodist Church itself is in favor of letting anyone join). And you thought the Hobby Lobby thing was complicated.

But...but...this is a religious institution founded 100+ years ago, they can't change! Actually, from what I can tell, this is a homeowner's association. I've given talks at churches and on the campuses of faith-based colleges and universities. They look and feel like churches. This looks and feels like a resort community. And it's lovely. And they did change their by-laws in 1959 when they removed the language forbidding non-white races from joining. So, change is possible. The members just need to vote that way. Last year's vote was split right down the middle.

So, knowing that I was about to give my big talk the next evening, I did what anyone with WiFi would have done, I Googled the heck out of this controversy. And most telling was a fifty-two page document by current and former Bay View members urging change. In it were statements like this:

No matter how tightly you wrap yourselves in the idea of freedom of religion, there is the foul odor of prejudice and racism in this position. During my interview, I was asked, “But what if more Jews wanted to join Bay View?” Implicit in this statement was the country club mentality of “we don’t want their kind among us.”

That's when I realized that by showing up, I'd accidentally stepped on flaming bag of dog-poop while wearing new shoes. I couldn't do my song and dance here because by doing so might imply tacit approval. So I talked to my publicist, my agent, and most importantly my wife who recommended that I do my thing, but use the spotlight as a teaching moment. (Um...yeah, that sounded like going into the lion's den and preaching veganism. But, hey, like with most things, she was right).

So my choices were:

1) Take my ball and go home. I could have cancelled. Packed my bags and left, which makes a certain kind of statement and would have been easy to do.

2) Dance, monkey, dance. I could have gone through with my normal event. Get check. Cash check. This actually would have been the hardest thing to do. I'm just not built that way. Some days, I wish I was. Life would be easier without a conscience.

3) Speak from the heart. And that's what I did. I turned down my speaking fee and gave a different kind of talk, one where I shared how my great-grandfather changed his last name from Chung to Ford so he could own property in Nevada. How my grandparents lived on Beacon Hill in Seattle because that was the only neighborhood in the city where a Chinese person could buy a house at the time. I talked about how it was illegal for my parents to get married in my mom's home state of Arkansas (they got married in California). And I talked about how the magic of this place vanished as soon as I realized the magic was only reserved for certain people. I expressed how Bay View was a wonderful community with a rich heritage and that I hoped they'd invite me back, and that if they did, I hoped I'd want to come back. It was a knee-trembling, voice-wavering, emotional speech and when I was done there was a round of thunderous applause, much to my relief.

Half of the community was thrilled that I spoke up. One woman from Louisville even gave me a "battlefield commission to Kentucky Colonel." The other half, not so much. But even a few of the angry ones still wanted me to sign their books.

I wrote "True love abides all."

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (8)

You and your wife are awesome. This was probably the most difficult choice as well as the most sensible.

Thanks for having the courage to speak your conscience.
July 25, 2014 | Unregistered Commenteradrienne
Awesome Jamie! Thank you for speaking from the heart.
July 25, 2014 | Unregistered CommenterDebbie Takami
Dang, Jamie. What a situation... I think you handled it with grace (as per usual). Nicely done. I hope (and believe) it will make a difference.
July 25, 2014 | Unregistered CommenterKristan
Thank you for speaking up. I am the woman who was turned down for membership in Bay View because I am Jewish (you quoted from my letter). This situation has been the source of enormous grief and heartache for me and my family. Your response to the Association was wonderful. Thank you.
July 26, 2014 | Unregistered CommenterAnne
Thanks Anne. And thank YOU for speaking up. I read the entire 52 pages the night before. It was incredibly helpful, educational, and revelatory. BV is a wonderful place. Very nice people. But change is scary for some.
July 26, 2014 | Unregistered CommenterJamie
As about to be former cottagers in Bay View, I am one of the folks who wrote a letter in that 52-page document you quote. After 42 years living in and raising our children in this place, we are---also out of conscience---selling our beloved cottage. Our four daughters cannot inherit the cottage because, although 2 of them are churched Christians, and all are deeply spiritual, they will not sign a religious litmus test and go through that bigoted, prejudiced membership screen to join. We applaud their decision. All are lovely, passionately committed civil servants and dearly love the community. But so, we are selling. If we can, which is doubtful. Some 40 cottages out of 450 are for sale, many of them by people like us. We have been working passionately for change and will continue to do so from our new home in nearby Petoskey. But as people of faith (with a small 'f'), we cannot continue to live where even children of the community are denied membership because of their beliefs or will not lie and claim they are 'churched', whatever that means. Thank you for lifting up our anguish to the larger world. You have a bully pulpit from which to do so and your courage to speak up here has helped those who believe in inclusiveness more than you know. As a novelist, my work is grounded on the joy and struggle of community building, a focus shaped by this place. My husband and my 2014 Bay View: Images of America (Arcadia) ends with our cottage for sale. We hope whoever buys it will not have the pain and grief we have experienced here.
July 26, 2014 | Unregistered CommenterMary A Agria
Jamie: Very well said. Like Mary Agria (above), I too am a former Bay View cottager now living in Petoskey. In Bay View’s defense, for its first 70 years the association welcomed everyone who was “of good moral character,” but in the 1940s a distinctly KKK way of thinking took hold there, and for a while blacks and Jews couldn’t even be in the place for more than one day (although the servants of southern members were kindly exempted from this restriction), and Catholics were assigned places on a quota list. The restriction on Jews is the last vestige of those days, but change comes very hard for many “Christians.”
July 29, 2014 | Unregistered Commenterdjkrause
Jamie: First, thank you for coming to Bay View to share your book with our community and enhancing our educational pillar. I am a Bay View member who supports the 52 page document you referenced and joined the majority of Bay View members who voted to change membership requirements. As you witnessed, it isn't just half who supported your statements, in fact the majority of current Bay View members voted to change the membership requirements and are continuing to work for change. I am very pleased you chose to speak out while here in Bay View, as I think it is important that our membership understands the impact on the larger community. However, I was disappointed that you used your blog to share your Google research with the world. As a writer in particular, I feel you should have given Bay View the benefit of real research prior to posting, so that you could explain how it "is complicated" and the rhetoric doesn't pertain to the entire community.

To the members above who are moving out of Bay View, I cannot tell you how sad this is. I think it is more important than ever that we who believe in a open Bay View, continue to grow the membership (in anyway possible) with members who will vote, support new by-laws, and take on leadership positions so that we can be the change we support.
August 1, 2014 | Unregistered CommenterBill

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.